Out of the Box


He used VertexTools from Thomthom.




Thanks @Cotty, it is indeed Vertex tools, one of my most often used tools.

If you mean freado’s excellent Box Twisting, part of Fredoscale, then No, it would give a very different result.
Fredo’s tool will slice the shape and make it curve, when subdivided it will tend to remain square and it doesn’t retain the quads so the SUbD is messy.
Vertex tools rotates the faces keeping the lines straight and maintaining the structure so that SUbD has clean quads to work on.


Yees, and I showed you that what you had suggested wouldn’t work in this case.


Can you not see in the gif the different results, the one on the right doesn’t form the fan shape when SUbD’d.


In the context of the question you were answering, the answer is still, No, in the case of creating this shape in this specific format, ie; a fan blade made using SUbD, fredo’s Box Twisting isn’t appropriate.


ok fredo wont twist it. nevermind.


You’re missing the point. I don’t care how Fabulous I am, you answered a question incorrectly, I corrected that by showing you why your suggestion doesn’t work in this case.

Fredo’s box twisting will twist things, but it wasn’t the tool I used and it wouldn’t have worked even if I did use it.


I give up.
You pointed out another plugin that can be used to twist things.
I showed you how that specific plugin doesn’t work in this specific instance. I didn’t chastise you or anything, I gave a demo of what happens with both options.
You insist your answer was relevant.
I point out that it wasn’t relevant in this case.
You get upset and delete everything.
Why? It was useful information on how certain plugins, while capable of doing virtually the same thing, don’t work in combination with other plugins.


This is a note to all contributors to this thread.

Sometimes the continuity of information in a given thread becomes disrupted or somewhat confusing when posts are deleted by the author…so in the future please consider how eliminating a previous post may affect the way the information is presented. There are times when it may be preferable to edit posts rather than to delete them entirely.


If you drew a flat fan blade, extruded it, and beveled the edges, then would Fredoscale be able to bend the fan blade into your desired shape?


On a lighter note, good stuff Box, keep it coming.