Why does solid tool turn component into group?

All of the native Solid Tools convert components they modify into groups. It’s the way the extension was written. Some years ago at 3D Basecamp I met the author of those tools and when I asked about this he said to me, “They’re broken.” I hoped they’d get fixed but he had already retired by that time and evidently fixing them isn’t a high enough priority for anyone else.

Instead of using the native Solid Tools, use Eneroth Solid Tools and/or Bool Tools 2. Both of them respect the “component-ness” of components. I have both because sometimes it seems one works better than the other depending on the objects involved.

3 Likes