Scene Tab "Not Updated" Cue

I would like to see a new automated visual cue added to SU scene tab labeling.

When a user selects a scene tab or one is active, and then makes any changes/modifications an “asterisk symbol” is added to the end of the scene tab label or the scene tab text changes to red or etc.

When the scene is updated or another scene is created and updated or if a different scene tab is selected the cue reverts back. I am submitting this request based upon my experience with using tabs in MS Expression Web4 (hopefully no patent limitations) which uses the asterisk symbol.

The purpose is to help new users and us multi-taskers keep track of whether a changed/modified scene has been updated.

5 Likes

I like this idea of having some clue that what you are looking at doesn’t match the selected scene tab.

1 Like

Yes, good idea.
The standard views have a notification in the top left of the model area (Top, Front , Left, etc)which disappears as soon as you move the camera, but scenes involve a lot more properties…

2 Likes

This is a good idea!

The circular update arrows over the style preview might also be a source of inspiration for designing this cue. Clicking it could update the scene. Maybe this fits better to the UX style of the web version than the desktop version though.

In any case, if a cue is added within the scene tab itself, I think some extra padding is needed so the scene tab doesn’t change size from showing or hiding the cue. Doing so would make all scenes jump a few pixels and would be quite annoying.

1 Like

I agree. I use adobe software primarily and have become accustomed to the asterisk appearing after the file name in the open document as soon as there are unsaved changes. It’s such a simple indicator but it says so much. It would adapt perfectly to the scene tabs and would be a welcome update for me.

1 Like

An alternative to a marker would be a change of font. That would minimize issues with the tab changing size.

But changing font wouldn’t tell what’s going on, unless you have read is a manual or been told that’s what it means. The asterisk is a quite widespread convention.

One way to fix the changing size issue would be to always “display” it, just in a transparent color when the scene is saved, making it invisible but still taking up its space.

Could just change the color of the scene tab or at least the text to red to alert the user.

1 Like

I don’t agree. Unless it is spelled out explicitly in words, a user always has to learn what a symbol means on a UI. Doesn’t make much difference whether it is a font, a color, an asterisk or some other marking. The user has to learn what it means. Asterisk may be widespread on Windows, but not so common on Mac I think.

1 Like

I can’t speak for mac but in the Window word this is definitely a widespread convention. Adobe, visual studio, SolidWorks, Sublime, Inkscape and AutoCad uses it, just to name a few. Possibly this could be a Windows only feature if Mac users aren’t used to this pattern. Also the word “Modified” could show up in a tooltip when hovering to make it more explicit, but that assumes the user knows what the word modified means.

Exactly. I would even make it more subtle, like a corner of the tab in red. Just enough to indicate changes, but not to distract.

Changing the font would certainly result in tab width changes, as font glyphs have wildly differing widths from font to font.

I don’t think their use of this convention is unique to Windows. From my experience, this is normal on macOS as well, at least in specific software packages.

1 Like