Which is better for using V Ray- Windows or Mac?

I really have nothing against Macs per say but every company (or organization) I’ve ever worked for has been Windows workstation, again this is probably due to the specific drafting, design and engineering software we were using:

Matlab, Catia, Solidworks, SketchUp, AutoCad, AutoDesk Inventor, STAAD, ANSYS, CosmosWorks, WoodWorks, RISA 3D, StruCalc, ArcGIS etc…

I think Macs are more dominant in the photography world and other art related trades.

Realistically Windows is still the dominant platform world wide. I think Linux has been gaining some ground recently and it catching up to MacOS in numbers recently.

Every company provided laptop I’ve ever used has been a Windows machine. Occasionally upper management would have a Mac laptop but it was typically a personal machine/preference and their actual company laptop was a Windows machine.

If I had the extra cash to blow, sure I’d buy myself a nice Mac just to have and play with but I’m not quite there yet.

The weird thing about this discussion is that the topic (be it Windows vs. macOS or MAC vs. PC) tries to make people narrow-minded and see the world only black and white! This reads really strange, if you worked in yet another field and discover neither of these both systems are tools adequate for to get the job done. Requirements are different and that’s why we need to differentiate – not only shades of gray but tones of colors.

It was kind of a brilliant coup by Apple to promote their software and hardware (now with identical CPU instruction set as Windows-compatible hardware) as a unit and coin all the diversity of everything else under a single “opponent” term “PC”. As if it was a single thing and there was only that single, worse alternative?

That’s totally fine for a marketing campaign (as is propaganda in politics), but taking over these terms is not a good basis for an objective discussion and evaluation and therefore I strongly vote for speaking either about hardware (and naming the manufacturer or CPU architecture) or operating systems (and naming them), as @moriah.teague did.

Who noticed that this is not a sailplane vs. a US spaceshuttle, but actually a Russian Buran on an Antonov AN-225?

Sometimes the best (if there can be such) is not what we thought. It is useful to look over the edge of the plate and see there are multiple alternatives and assess them on your own before deciding.

3 Likes

I use windows 10 but I am upgrading to MacBook Pro in about 5-6 months

100% Mac for sk and other creative things eg graphic design and music production
Check out my 3D warehouse
https://3dwarehouse.sketchup.com/user/349ac699-5c33-4929-b8c2-9480b2a712a2/Hector-V?nav=models

The Original Poster asked a very specific question that wasn’t is PC better than Mac?
All those posts that have wandered off from answering that specific question should be noted as off topic and removed from the thread. Mine included.
@moriah.teague asked a legitimate question about how V Ray performs with the different OS’, anything else is irrelevant.

3 Likes

You’re probably right, but the current discussion is so much more interesting.

In the same way as Catholic V Protestants, Rep V Dem, opinionated V self opinionated…is more interesting.
The forum is about helping and answering questions. Subjective opinions don’t answer questions.

3 Likes

3 Likes

Come on, what is life without a little fun once in a while.

Seriously though, look at the title of this thread, that is an awfully loaded question. I’m actually surprised the conversation isn’t more spirited than it is.

Which actually brings me to a related (but probably off topic) question. What are the advantages to running SketchUp on a Mac? If there are enough advantages or reasons then it might give me cause enough to consider switching…

All I can say is they are two very offensive posts showing a total lack of understanding of the world around them.

3 Likes

NetMarketShare: Operating System Market Share: Desktop: Windows vs. Mac OS vs. Linux

This is again going off-topic. Let’s stop it here.

What do you count? Desktops? Desktops and mobile? Desktops and mobile and IoT and cars? Statistics without reference are wild claims. Statistics with reference are freely biased depending on choice of source. And how is it relevant – in an interconnected world where the production and delivery of any product or content that you consume involve a variety of systems?

This discussion leads to nothing and does not answer the OP’s question.

:white_check_mark:

relax… if this would be the benchmark lots of stuff here shouldn’t have been posted at all.

I deleted my comment well before you replied to it.

I did answer the OPs original question yesterday also.

1 Like

Isn’t that the point.
In a world where it is becoming the norm that if you say it loud enough and often enough it is true, some of us want to answer questions with answers not alternate facts. In this case we just want to answer the question asked, not all possible permutations of the various words in the question.

1 Like

So, steering back tward topic. Does anyone know of a formal or informal list of the differences in the UI between the two operating systems. It would be useful to know when deciding about switching, and useful for me when answering questions across platforms on the forum.

2 Likes

of course, but we did not live in a perfect world and posting this in every thread with OTs would create additional noise on top of the OT itself… as you can see above.

Towards, but not on topic. Topic is, which OS works best with V Ray?

If you use V Ray and can give a review on how V Ray works on both systems then you are on topic.

1 Like

I can’t understand what you could possibly mean by this,

1 Like