My Background & Workflow
I work on translating or making 3D concepts into buildable drawings for various industries:
- Carpenters and metalworkers
- Model makers (CNC files and 3D printing)
- Special effects teams
My typical workflow involves receiving models from concept artists (Maya, Rhino, Blender, SolidWorks) or creating them myself in Blender, Rhino, or SketchUp.
Why I’m Reconsidering SketchUp
What I love about SketchUp: Its ease of use and intuitive interface for conceptual work has made it my preferred tool for years.
Recent challenge: After using Rhino 8 extensively, I’ve noticed their significant focus on 2D documentation improvements in their recent release. While Rhino is less intuitive and has more glitches, their recent updates are impressive and address many drafting needs that SketchUp Layout currently reluctant to improve.
Layout’s Untapped Potential
I believe Trimble has a huge opportunity to develop Layout into a drafting tool that surpasses AutoCAD LT level capabilities. Here’s what I think Layout needs:
Key Improvements Needed:
- Enhanced Fill/Hatch Capabilities.
- Boolean like operations for fills/hatches. (ArchiCAD still leads in this area)
- Better Drafting Tools
- More precise drawing and editing tools (Mirror, SketchUp tools like divide…)
- Workflow Improvements
- Build upon the existing viewport system that already works well
Interface & Shortcuts Issues:
Positive: The introduction of some SketchUp shortcuts into Layout was welcome
Frustrating: Layout shortcuts cannot be imported/exported - this seems like a basic feature that’s missing
Request: More SketchUp commands should work the same way in Layout (while keeping useful Layout-specific features like arrow key nudging)
My Experience Across Software
Having worked in film design and architecture with many software packages over the last 25 years (some now discontinued), I still prefer SketchUp’s approach. However, Layout really needs to step up to remain competitive.
What I’m Planning
When I return to SketchUp/Layout from my current Rhino work, I’ll compile a detailed list of specific improvements needed and share it here.
Call to Action
I’d love to hear from others: What Layout improvements would make the biggest difference in your workflow?
I understand Trimble faces the challenge of adding powerful features while preserving SketchUp’s greatest strength - its intuitive, user-friendly interface. But I believe it’s possible to achieve both.