Component definitions in ifc files

From my understanding of where things stand, the native import/export facilities within SU (2024) are still very much Work In Progress.
There is a (small ?) team under @olivia_feng working on these aspects of SU & they now seem to be aware of the (major) issues that need sorting, but maybe what needs to happen is that they organise a virtual seminar with a bunch of us who are trying to use SU in BIM workflows in order to make sure they have a full picture of what works & what doesn’t ?

thats a really good idea.

1 Like

:pray: let’s hope they do, It feels as if we are a (small ?) band of regular contributors on the forum pertaining to BIM/IFC issues and rather than talk to us individually, once in a while a collective discussion would help everyone, including the Dev team… Let’s see if the idea gets any traction !

I think you mean IfcRelDefinesByType :slight_smile: the authoring software must map each Component accordingly, too

2 Likes

I hope so too. Although there should have been someone from BuildingSmart, they are in fact the ones who Knows perfectly what is needed to be certified by them.
I would love for Sketchup to be on this list. IFC Certified Software - buildingSMART International

1 Like

Yes quite right !! Me too… way back in 2018 I think SU was on the list !

Thanks for reporting the issue; my team has received a similar issue from other testers. We are currently looking into the problem. Can you share the original IFC file with us so the team can take a look? Also we are looking for users to do more IFC workflow-related research. I will reach out to you for an interview !

Olivia

1 Like

Here’s the file I used for comparison, zipped
Staal.ifc.zip (633.3 KB)
. It´s made in Trimble Tekla I think. I would be happy to contribute with sharing my experiences on ifc workflows.