Steven - well said
Thank-you for some well put together thoughts and comments. I do appreciate this kind of feedback and I will do my best to provide an equivalent and coherent response:
1.) I agree that the user extensibility is a key piece to the success of this plugin. Initially I started with outlets and switches (as well as low voltage, and panels) where this is less of a concern however with other electrical devices I am providing a system whereby the user can utilize their own components: lights, safety devices, heaters, vents. Currently the user cannot edit or utilize their own categories (and corresponding 2D symbols) however to enable this level of customization also requires that the user be able to determine which parameters are applicable to that category (ie. ceiling vs. wall mounted), so it does become a bit more complicated than at first blush.
I also was looking at this plugin from the point of the more casual user (DIYer) who does not have the inclination nor the experience to develop a whole host of electrical devices (accurate and low poly) to populate the (empty) plugin’s library folders. So at the very least I needed to provide some basic switches, outlets and other standard devices. I wanted a certain “out-of-the-box” aspect to this plugin, but at the same time allowing the more advanced user the ability to customize and extend the plugin to meet their needs. If anything I feel like I need to provide more pre-built components, high quality components that either are packaged with the plugin or are provided as optional “packs” that can be installed at the users discretion.
2.) Initially I only meant to spend at most about 2 weeks of my time on this plugin but as I developed it further both in real terms and conceptually it has managed to absorb more time and energy than initially projected. There really has been very little in scope creep, surprising based on my history with all of my other plugins, but my 2 week time frame stretched out into a 2 month period. This is not to say I have not been working on other plugins, its just that I’ve been stretched very thin, now dividing my time between five different plugin projects as well as the engineering tools on my website. I actually spent about a week of my time last month reworking and updating my wind speed algorithms within the Medeek API and Basic Wind Speed Map. I’ve also been forced to update many of the Google maps API calls (dynamic and static maps) on my online design criteria maps due to Google changing their system and BREAKING my website, unfortunately that is still an ongoing project. Then to top it off my new server I installed at the beginning of March began to have hardware issues which required me to yet again divert my attention away from the plugin development.
We will get there with the shed and gable walls, perhaps in the next couple of weeks I will finally be able to release this feature for public consumption. I have returned my focus to the Wall plugin with the release of this latest feature (electrical symbols legend).
To be perfectly honest I am at a point where I now realize that to reach the goal posts in a reasonable amount of time I need to somehow increase not only the speed of my development but also the breadth. In short, I could really use some help with all of these plugins and the burgeoning to-do lists associated with each. However, as always it comes down to user uptake. In order to accelerate my development I need more revenue but I’m already pushing the limits as far as what the SketchUp community will accept with regards to pricing levels of these plugins. I have purposely kept the larger plugins below the $100 mark, this seems to be the magic number. If the plugins are priced above this mark the uptake begins to take a noticeable and dramatic downturn.
So it comes down to volume of sales. The number of architects (and other design professionals) in the US and worldwide who use SketchUp as their primary design tool is unknown to me, however my theory is that this number is still not very large when compared to users of AutoCad, Revit, Chief Architect and possibly other platforms/packages. Right out of the gate this puts me at a serious disadvantage, rather than thousands of possible users there are probably only hundreds of potential users of the plugins. Then you must factor in that only a certain percentage of these design professionals will actually jump on board, some have their own work flow and rely primarily on the native tools (what I call extension aversion) or they may have other plugins or solutions that they gravitate towards (ie. PlusSpec, Housebuilder, Profile Builder etc…)
The question really is are their enough potential users of the plugins to fully support their development? I don’t have the answer to the that question but so long as I have enough revenue coming in to just squeak by I will keep plugging away at it and if the day every comes that I can bring on additional help to speed things up, then I most certainly will.
When and if that day ever comes you will see not only a timely maturation of the current plugins but also a proliferation of new ideas and plugins that will literally blow your socks off.
Version 1.0.6 - 04.15.2019
- Added additional NEMA 240V receptacles into the Outlet module: NEMA 6-30R, NEMA 6-50R.
These additional receptacles (and symbols) were per customer request.
Tutorial 3: Electrical Symbols Legend
Since adding the symbols legend I’ve had a number of requests for a tool to draw a schedule (similar to how I am drawing the legend).
Now that I’ve got a fairly solid routine for pulling the electrical data (I will use much of this same code for the estimating tool) it isn’t too big of a leap to draw a schedule.
My question is what information do you need or want in this schedule, how do you want it laid out? Every device listed with its parameters or do I group like devices?
Please give feedback in this regard. Also feel free to send me any sample electrical schedules that I can utilize as references.
If I know what I want to output I can probably knock this out in 2-3 hours, most of the underlying code is already in place.
In the plans I look at every day, there’s an electrical schedule! But what I do see are lighting schedules.
They’re all fairly consistent in design. For each type of lighting fixture (called out on the plans usually by a tag on each instance), there is a simple columnar table with only two columns. The first column matches the call out on the plan and the second column details whatever the architect wants to say to specify the fixture. Really nice architects include a 3rd column: A count of each fixture type! Unless the project is really large, the fixture “types” are denoted with a single, capital letter, with (if necessary) a single number following designating a variant of the basic fixture.
For instance: Fixture C1 might be some type of fluorescent fixture. C2 the same fixture with a dimmable ballast, C3 the same fixture with an emergency battery in the fixture, C4 is the long version, etc. etc. etc.
For the REST of the electrical, most of the extra information beyond the symbol will be found in notes, either specific notes from a call out on the plan, or a series of general notes usually on the E1 sheet of the plans.
For most job, there will be a single line diagram (The one for the 42 story job I’m currently managing the flow of material to the job runs to 3 full plan sized sheets!) outlining the power flow beginning at the utility feed, through switchboards, meters, safety switches, and transformers, ending at one or more panels.
For each panel, there is a schedule which details each distribution panel, shown diagramatically including the intended position of each circuit breaker within the panel, how many watts (NOT kilowatts) each breaker POLE will draw from which electrical phase, Along with common essential information (Indoor or outdoor? Flush or surface trim? Voltage and configuration of the feed to the panel. Main Breaker or Main Lug Only? If Main Breaker, what amperage? Roughly 50% of the time, the buss material is included (otherwise we just use Aluminum, the cheapest). And there’s blank space for any less usual information (200% Neutral, Feed Thru Lugs, Extra Gutter Space, etc.) Also these days, the need for branch circuit breakers to be Arc Fault, Ground Fault, or Dual Function is frequently part of the schedule.
For the electrical devices which Medeek Electrical makes to easy to place, I’ve NEVER seen a set of plans that calls out the box! At most, there will be wording in the plans, in the Electrical Specifications section, that requires the use of a particular brand, or “all boxes must be metallic”, rarely (and on large projects only) will I see exact boxes called out and when I do, it’s in a specification like “Electric Boxes and Wiring shall …” and continue with a bunch of obscure stuff that narrows the choice down to a single brand’s particular rapid installation alternative and end with “Such as Cooper Wiring Devices EzInstall System (or approved equivalent)” Note: I made up the “EzInstall” and it’s usually impossible to find an equivalent that the specifier will approve!
What would help me, the electrical distributor, would be a device schedule somewhat akin to the fixture schedule, but generic - and with counts! Something like:
24 15A 120V Tamper Resistant Duplex Receptacles, Commercial Grade.
27 15A Single Pole, Decorator Style Switches.
Etc. Etc. Etc.
Now THAT would be a real timesaver! I’ve spent HOURS doing “take offs” manually counting these things.
@MikeWayzovski I created my alternate ego, "at"sjdorst-doppleganer, for a very specific and limited purpose - to have an alternate identity with my work hardware, OS, and License type in the profile. I’ll be using it only when (actually, I’m hoping it’s “if”) I need advice that is specific to my work machine - hardware and License problems only. Other than that, I’m going to do all my posting under my normal handle “at” sjdorst.
I’ve been trying to add the Electrical extension to the warehouse since February but for whatever reason the system will not allow me to add a listing. Perhaps someone can help me expedite this process, I would really like to get this plugin out to the general audience, I think a lot of people will find it useful and even affordable.
I suggest you post this, with a few more details of what you see as not working to the Extension Warehouse Category:
Looks like the listing is finally live in the Extension Warehouse:
To celebrate the inclusion of this new extension into the Extension Warehouse and to further accelerate its uptake I will be running an Easter special.
This special is a little different than those I have recently done in the past.
In order to obtain a full license for the Electrical Extension at no cost all you need to do is renew one of your existing licenses for any other Medeek extension (Truss, Wall or Foundation). Purchase of a new license for any of these three plugins is also a valid option as well.
Once you have purchased either a renewal or new license of the Truss, Wall or Foundation plugin(s) then please send me an email and I will issue you a license for the Medeek Electrical extension. If you already own the electrical extension I will issue a renewal to your existing license, thereby extending it license expiration date an additional year.
If you renew more than one extension, only one renewal can be applied towards a free license or renewal of the Electrical extension.
This promotion is only valid for purchases and renewals from 04-24-2019 thru 05-01-2019, there will be no exceptions.
Version 1.0.7 - 04.28.2019
- Fixed the show_modal bug for macOS in the Materials tab of the global settings.
As a celebration of the 4th of July and the full parameterization of the Foundation plugin I will be offering an incentive on new purchases or renewals of the Truss, Foundation or Wall plugins.
If you purchase or renew any of the BIM plugins on the 4th of July (tomorrow) you will be entitled to a complimentary license for the Medeek Electrical extension. This promotion is only valid on the 4th of July.
I will be taking most of the day off tomorrow (finally) and eating some good food and watching some fireworks on the beach.
Happy 4th of July!
I haven’t made any updates to this plugin since April but I am still open to ideas and improvements. Please let me know if there is something you would like me to add or a feature that needs improvement.
A couple of things worth noting after working with a customer via Skype this morning:
1.) If your custom walls have reversed faces this will affect the plugin. The solution is to jump into the group, right click on the face in question and reverse the face.
2.) The plugin calculates the bottom of the wall by looking at the origin of the group that is the container for the wall geometry. If the origin of this group is below or above the bottom of the wall then the vertical distance for positioning various electrical fixtures (ie. switches, outlets, data etc…) will not be correct. I may change this up to consider the lowest point of the face rather than the origin of the group, I will need to give this some additional thought.
For the month of September I will be running the following promotion:
If you purchase or renew any of the BIM plugins during the month of September you will be entitled to a complimentary license for the Medeek Electrical extension. This promotion is only valid until September 30th.
Note, that if you already own an existing license for the electrical plugin then this promotion will allow you to further extend your license expiration of that plugin by an additional year.
If you purchased or renewed one of the other extensions in the previous two weeks (Sept 1 thru Sept 14) you are also retroactively eligible for this promotion, please contact me via email to take advantage of this offer.