I’m guessing, but it looks like they are both some form of intersection of sine wave with parabola. I did a thread on making a sine wave here.
Creating solid objects and then using solid tools to do the intersection seems like the way to go, I would think. What did you use to Merge the shapes?
Hahaha! I should know better than to just wait for @DaveR to nail it. Ok, the partial elipse is just a stretched half-circle, but distributing the sine wave around the rim - do you need flowify, or is there a simpler way?
For the dome I use a profile and circular path with Follow Me. The dome shape is a parabola drawn with the Classic Bezier tool from Fredo6’s Bezier Spline set. Offset to make a thin profile and wind up with a solid component.
For the sine curve, I started with a 3-cycle sine curve made with Curve Maker. I added a few edges to get a face which I extruded to make it 3D. Then ThomThom’s True Bend to make the circular shape which is also a solid.
Then I used Trim from Eneroth Solid Tools to trim the dome.
It may not match the original exactly but since it isn’t likely this will be needed for engineering drawings to make the lamp shade, I’m sure it’ll be close enough.
Wow.
I think this is all a bit above my skill level. Any way to break this down in to step by step laymans terms?
I also posted on the podium forum and got the response here: Help With Building Sinneman Light Fixtures - SU Podium Forum
I was able to build the dome shape but extruding the curve (step J) left me with a whole mess. Not sure how to create the back curve.
That should be workable in general. Cleaning up the unwanted bits after that can be a bit fussy. Using solid tools where possible can leave less mess, but does the same thing basically. From what @DaveR said, he chose Eneroth’s Solid Tools to do that rather than the native ones.
I prefer Eneroth Solid Tools because they don’t convert components to groups. In the example I made, I didn’t bother about the size of the model but if I’d been modeling it as something I wanted at the correct size, I would have started the model with the shade at the given dimensions and then used the Dave Method for trimming the bottom. The native Solid Tools don’t allow that method to work.
Split tools is a combination of Split Donut, Split Sausage and Split up tools and brings them together along with a toolbar that Box shows.
In the gif you can see there is what is known as a donut, that needs breaking into “quads” for Subd to work nicely with the geometry. You don’t “need” the Split Tools to break the donut and make the Quads, you could just draw edges in manually if you like. But it’s much easier being able to automate the process.
I didn’t suggest it as a quick fix, SUbD is a whole other way of thinking with other tools and things to learn before you are proficient.
Having said that, did you click the first button on the toolbar? as it looks like you have only clicked the one that turns edges off.
If that isn’t the case I’d need to see your model to understand what is wrong with it.
Couldn’t help myself, had to get in on the fun. Got the pendent light modeled with Vertex Tools and SubD. Box is correct that there is a definite learning curve to using these tools. Would have to say I wouldn’t pick this lampshade for someone new to the tools. Hope the images give you an idea how I got there.
I like to make myself crazy… Had to try the sconce. The reference pics aren’t the greatest. Took a while messing about to get the proxy shaped up for SubD. It’s pretty darn close to the correct measurements of the real deal and will sit flat to the wall. Not sure if I got that close but you can’t tell from a runaway horse .
This has been percolating away in the back of my mind, particularly a way to make a wavy circle face without using plugins, so I woke up with this in mind.
Certainly not a sine wave but a method to make floppy disks. A wave at 60deg or whatever you choose and whatever amount of curve. If you angle the arcs the wave becomes smoother.
Then using it to make a light fitting, I’ve made no attempt to make this look right, just a technique.
This is fantastic. You guys are Sketchup gurus!
Thank you so much for breaking it down for me. Hopefully at some point with practice I’ll speak the lingo and master the extensions… But for now, the step by step really helps!
Going to attempt @Box ‘s step by step when I’m back in the office on Tuesday.
Thank you again!
I finally looked at the image, I rarely follow links, you should add images directly to the post. On this one I angled the arcs at 30 rather than the blue axis, gives a much smoother wave. This is pretty much what @DaveR showed in about the third or fourth post, just no use of plugins at all.Offset the oval before follow me and flip the wave and you create a fully solid structure.